CapiaLet’s talk

Analysis Business and society

Barometer 2020X: what do young adults think about Northern Norway and the future?

Barometer 2020X: what do young adults think about Northern Norway and the future?

Barometer 2020X: what do young adults think about Northern Norway and the future?

About the story

Original article

Translated from the original publication. Dates and historical information are retained.

Written for Kunnskapsbanken:

In the Barometer 2020X survey, we asked young adults across Northern Norway a range of questions about life in the region.

A total of 574 Northern Norwegians aged 18–34 spent a combined 4.5 days answering questions about how the region should develop.

Here we examine the most interesting findings.

Pride and geographic attachment among young adults

Fifty-eight per cent feel very strongly attached to Northern Norway, higher than their attachment to Norway, their county or their town or municipality. County attachment is weakest: only 34 per cent feel very strongly attached to their county.

Almost everyone is proud of nature: 98 per cent are fairly or very proud of Northern Norway’s natural environment.

The figure shows the share fairly or very proud of Northern Norway across different categories.

National political influence and influence in public debate rank lowest, with 14 and 22 per cent respectively fairly or very proud of the region’s role.

The economy also ranks relatively low, at 42 per cent, despite Northern Norway’s faster value-added growth than the rest of Norway in recent years. These results are consistent across gender, age, residence and other characteristics.

Involvement in local decisions

Only 24 per cent partly or fully agree that their county or municipality considers residents’ input in important decisions. Results are consistent across gender, residence, education and other characteristics.

Many young adults therefore believe resident input is not considered in important decisions. How would they like to be involved?

What matters locally, and what are young adults satisfied with?

A detailed overview is available in Telleren through the source link.

Healthcare matters most: 98 per cent consider local services important or very important. It is also the service with the highest satisfaction: 65 per cent are satisfied or very satisfied.

Social meeting places, support for sustainable industry and jobs, leisure activities and education opportunities matter to more than 90 per cent. Among these, support for sustainable industry and jobs has the lowest satisfaction, at only 33 per cent.

Public transport and population growth measures rank lowest for satisfaction, at 23 and 21 per cent. Both matter to more than 75 per cent.

Education opportunities also deserve attention: only slightly more than half are satisfied locally. Opportunities are not the same as educational quality, but Nordland, Troms and Finnmark have had Norway’s highest upper-secondary dropout shares over the past five years.

The Centre for Economic Research’s 2016 report also found upper-secondary school quality in these counties considerably below all other Norwegian counties.

Our findings can be compared with the Residents’ Survey 2019, regularly conducted by Difi for the Ministry of Local Government and Modernisation. Northern Norway scored below average in every category concerning opportunities for activities.

Working in Northern Norway

Salary expectations among employed young adults and students

Employed young adults have somewhat lower salary expectations than those in education. One possible explanation is that students more often expect careers with higher pay than those currently working.

Only half fully or partly agree that working in Northern Norway offers good career opportunities. Among students, however, 84 per cent expect relevant regional employment after graduation.

Forty-five per cent of employed young adults expect to change employer within two years. Most search using NAV, Finn.no, Jobbnorge.no or similar job portals; almost half use personal networks. Nearly 40 per cent use social media. Newspapers and LinkedIn are used relatively little, with seven and ten per cent respectively naming them among their main job-search channels.

Most are satisfied with work–life balance: almost eight per cent are dissatisfied, while over 70 per cent are satisfied or very satisfied.

We also asked what flexibility employers should offer. Slightly fewer than one-quarter want fewer working days with longer hours each day.

Forty per cent want flexible hours outside core hours, the most popular working-time flexibility option.

After months of home working for many, attitudes to this arrangement were also interesting.

Do young adults want future home-working options? Only ten per cent want a permanent arrangement for some weekdays, and only two per cent want it for all working hours. By contrast, 59 per cent want to work from home when needed.

An earlier survey of highly educated workers found over 60 per cent enjoyed home working. However, around 80 per cent felt it weakened professional community and missed social contact, most strongly among under-30s. This fits Barometer 2020X: few young Northern Norwegians want home working as a permanent solution.

Where do young adults expect to live in the future?

Where do those expecting to leave the region currently live?

Young adults in the largest cities are most likely to expect a move. Almost 30 per cent in Tromsø and Bodø—the only Northern Norwegian municipalities at level 3 in Statistics Norway’s centrality index—expect to move abroad or elsewhere in Norway within five years. The share is below 20 per cent in the rest of the region.

One important explanation may be the large student populations expecting to move after graduation. The least central municipalities, levels 5 and 6, have the highest share expecting to remain in their municipality.

Almost 70 per cent of those expecting to stay have paid work as their main activity, compared with fewer than half of those expecting to move.

Students form a considerably larger share of those expecting to move, whether within or outside Northern Norway.

Younger respondents are also more likely to expect a move: fewer than half of 18–24-year-olds expect to remain in their present municipality.

Does upbringing matter? We asked where respondents had lived longest. Among those raised outside Northern Norway, over 40 per cent expect to leave the region.

Among those who lived longest in the north, people from Nordland are slightly more likely to expect to leave: 18 per cent, against 15 per cent among those raised in Troms and Finnmark.

This aligns with Statistics Norway’s population projections, which expect higher domestic out-migration from Nordland than Troms and Finnmark towards 2025.

We also examined education, other demographics, and views of Northern Norway. Are there substantial differences between people expecting to remain and those expecting to leave?

Only slightly more than one-quarter of expected leavers fully or partly agree that working in Northern Norway offers good career opportunities.

Among those expecting to remain in five years, well over half agree.

Could limited career opportunities partly explain young adults leaving the north?

Jobs matter to most people, but are not the only factor in residential choices. Other local qualities can influence decisions to stay or move. What matters, and how satisfied are people with local services and measures? Again, we compare expectations of residence in five years.

We asked about the importance of support for sustainable industry and jobs and satisfaction with the current situation.

The table shows shares considering such measures important or very important and satisfied or very satisfied. More than 85 per cent value them regardless of expected future residence. People in less central areas are more satisfied than those in central areas.

The largest difference concerns satisfaction with leisure activities.

More than 85 per cent value these regardless of expected residence. Among those expecting to remain in Northern Norway, over 60 per cent are satisfied or very satisfied, against fewer than 40 per cent of expected leavers.

Arts and cultural activities are considered less important, but satisfaction is again lowest among those expecting to leave. Residents of the most central areas are most satisfied.

Few are especially satisfied with current conditions, but expected leavers are least satisfied. Among those expecting to stay in their current municipality, 37 per cent are satisfied with current measures, compared with just over one-quarter among those expecting to move.

Education opportunities are very important to more than 90 per cent, and slightly more than half are satisfied locally. Only among those expecting to leave Northern Norway does satisfaction fall below half.

Education and continuing education among young adults

Northern Norway’s higher-education attainment is below the national average. Here we examine young adults’ views of regional education opportunities.

We also examine continuing and further education: do many expect to pursue it within ten years? Could employers lose staff if they do not support it?

What format should educational institutions offer to attract young Northern Norwegian adults?

More than 90 per cent consider local education opportunities important or very important, whether in cities or small municipalities. Satisfaction, however, varies greatly geographically. We group respondents by their municipality’s centrality.

Bodø and Tromsø are the region’s most central municipalities at level 3. Level 4 includes Alta, Narvik and Vefsn; level 5 includes Karasjok, Målselv and Brønnøy. Level 6 includes the least central municipalities, such as Vega, Nordkapp and Karlsøy.

Eighty-four per cent of young adults in Tromsø and Bodø are satisfied with local education opportunities.

Outside those cities and centrality level 3, fewer than half are satisfied.

Sixty-seven per cent expect to pursue continuing or further education within ten years. The largest difference is by gender: 75 per cent of women, against 61 per cent of men.

The pattern is similar across age and geography, with comparable shares in cities and small places and throughout ages 18–34.

Are they willing to move for further education? Those expecting to pursue it were asked whether they would relocate to do so.

Almost half of women are unwilling, compared with around 35 per cent of men.

Willingness declines with age: three-quarters of 18–24-year-olds are willing to move, but fewer than one-quarter of 30–34-year-olds. Geography matters too: young adults in the least central municipalities are less willing to relocate than city residents.

Are they willing to change jobs for further education? More than 70 per cent of both women and men would change jobs if their employer did not make arrangements for it.

The share is slightly higher among the youngest, with little urban–rural difference. Employers may therefore need to support further education to avoid losing ambitious employees.

Would young adults accept lower income to pursue further education? Around half would, with men slightly more willing than women. Age differences are large: 18–24-year-olds are considerably more willing than 30–34-year-olds.

Among 30–34-year-olds, a considerably larger share would undertake further education only if their employer paid. This condition is also more common in central areas.

Which format do they prefer? An overwhelming majority have a clear favourite: more than 69 per cent want a combination of digital and in-person teaching.

Which continuing-education format do you prefer?

In-person-only education is most popular among the youngest, at 21 per cent. They are least likely to prefer digital-only provision, at four per cent. Seventy-two per cent prefer a combination.

Digital-only education is most popular in the least central areas, at 17 per cent, but 63 per cent there still prefer a combination. In-person teaching is most popular among those expecting to leave Northern Norway, yet even there only 25 per cent prefer it.

More than two-thirds of young adults therefore expect further education within ten years. This is good news, especially given skilled-labour shortages in both the public sector and businesses.

Employers can respond to this clear demand by enabling staff to undertake further education. Otherwise, they risk losing ambitious employees.

Educational institutions should develop blended digital and in-person provision to attract students and help raise Northern Norway’s education levels.

Method

The digital Barometer 2020X survey targeted Northern Norwegian adults aged 18–34 and ran from 4 to 30 September 2020. A total of 648 respondents completed it. Seventy-four responses were excluded, leaving 574 for analysis. Exclusions included invalid answers, such as nonexistent postcodes, or logical inconsistencies, such as denying discrimination exists while reporting having observed it during the previous six months.

Responses were weighted by gender, age and residence to improve representativeness. Overrepresented groups received lower weights and underrepresented groups higher weights.

The survey was shared openly through social media, Kunnskapsbanken Nord-Norge’s website, the Nye Stemmer network and Samfunnsløftet at SpareBank 1 Nord-Norge.

For many questions, we examined centrality differences rather than county differences. Statistics Norway’s index classifies municipalities by centrality. Bodø and Tromsø are Northern Norway’s most central at level 3, while the least central are level 6. Comparing levels reveals urban–rural differences. We focused on centrality because county differences were often modest, while centrality differences were considerably larger and therefore offered greater insight.

Sources and references

Historical context

This story is based on an earlier publication. It describes the work and data at that time and is not an updated market report.

Source

← Back to insights