About the story
Original article
Translated from the original publication. Dates and historical information are retained.
Written for Kunnskapsbanken:
“Transmission in Norway is still not that extensive,” Prime Minister Erna Solberg told parliamentary question time on 11 March 2020. But what awaits us in one or two weeks?
“Transmission in Norway is still not that extensive,” she said. Everything is relative: as of 12 March, Norway has the third-highest number of registered infections per million residents. Italy leads by a substantial margin, followed by South Korea. Meanwhile, the head of the World Health Organization is concerned about “alarming levels of inaction” against transmission. We examine Norway’s and Italy’s figures. What might Norway face in one or two weeks?
Mark Handley, a professor at University College London, recently shared a chart on Twitter showing confirmed COVID-19 cases in different countries. COVID-19 is the disease caused by coronavirus.
The chart shows several countries following Italy’s trajectory with a one- to two-week delay. Handley argues that all these countries except Japan will resemble Italy in nine to 14 days. All of Italy is now under quarantine, with only pharmacies and grocery stores open. We do not know how long the measures will last or whether they will succeed.
Norway was not included in his chart. Using Johns Hopkins University data, we create a similar comparison of Norway and Italy, shifting Norway’s figures by 13 days. The latest data are for 11 March.
Will Norway’s situation in 13 days resemble Italy’s today, with nationwide quarantine and only groceries and pharmacies open? Not necessarily. The charts show registered infections, which are not the same as actual infections. If no one is tested, no one will be registered as infected. How many people are actually infected in Norway and Italy when we only have registered case counts? Research papers argue that actual infections in countries including Italy and the United States are substantially higher than recorded cases.
Death counts provide a very rough indication of country differences. Norway currently has more recorded infections without a single death than any other country. This could partly reflect lower mortality in Norway. More likely, it mainly reflects actual infections not greatly exceeding registered cases, and the disease having arrived relatively recently. Italy recorded its first death on 21 February. On 27 February it had 655 confirmed cases—roughly Norway’s number today—but already 17 deaths. Deaths increased considerably in the following days.
Assuming relatively similar disease mortality in Norway and Italy, Italy must in reality have had far more infections two weeks ago than the 655 recorded, whereas Norway’s zero deaths suggest a relatively good overview of infections. This had major implications for Italian transmission: many undetected infections allowed rapid spread, contributing to the present situation. Italy’s sharp increase in registered cases over the last two weeks does not directly represent actual transmission either. Recorded cases rise both when newly infected people are tested and when people infected for some time are eventually tested. A similar pattern has occurred in China.
More testing produces more recorded infections, and Norway is among the countries that have tested the most residents. We do not know whether Italy’s actual increase in new infections has exceeded or fallen below its increase in recorded cases.
Although Norway’s recent recorded case trajectory closely resembles Italy’s 13 days earlier, several factors suggest Norway now has a better starting point. Italy recorded its first death on 21 February, while Norway has none yet. Norway also has better oversight and probably far fewer infections than Italy had two weeks ago. Italy’s experience warns what may happen if measures come too late. Although Norway’s recorded infections should be expected to rise substantially in the coming weeks, the measures now being implemented will hopefully produce a smaller increase in infections and deaths than Italy has experienced over the last two weeks.
References
A research paper examining actual and recorded infections in China. After strict quarantine measures were implemented, growth in actual infections slowed, while recorded cases continued to increase for some time because of expanded testing and detection of earlier infections. As growth in actual infections subsided, recorded case growth also declined, with a delay: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2762130
A research paper supporting the argument that infections in Italy have been underreported: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.02.20030049v1
A research paper indicating that United States infections have probably also been underreported: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.06.20031880v1
Sources and references
Historical context
This story is based on an earlier publication. It describes the work and data at that time and is not an updated market report.
